Brian Viglione - Oh Comely (Neutral Milk Hotel Cover)

AwesomeMandy Says:

Sep 28, 2007 - AWESOME!

ccmia Says:

Oct 13, 2007 - Brian is awesome, hot and talented.

t3mpusfugit Says:

Nov 1, 2007 - I was skeptical while first listening to this... but I love it now.

gorramdoll Says:

Dec 20, 2007 - I love that the audience was so excited when they recognized this song. Good for Brian covering it.

gorramdoll Says:

Dec 20, 2007 - actually now that I've listened to it I really don't like his singing, but he still rules.

alphaweltal Says:

Dec 21, 2007 - My favorite song ever made, covered by half my favorite band. Yes!

kiek Says:

Jan 12, 2008 - This is so cute<3

franley07 Says:

Jan 30, 2008 - beautiful. xx

sweetallie22 Says:

Feb 5, 2008 - skeptical haha

limmy003 Says:

Feb 9, 2008 - i love you, brian viglione. have for many years. and you SING!!! holy shit you should have a lot more vocal parts on the records. just... wow. you've blown me away. again. ♥

ruddegore Says:

Feb 9, 2008 - this made me wanna look up neutral milk hotel, i love it, so meloncholy

pymberly Says:

Feb 29, 2008 - One of the best songs ever made, being covered by half of the greatest band I've heard in a long while.

NicoleAnachronism Says:

Mar 11, 2008 - wow, so the dresden dolls are my favorite band and oh comely is my favorite song ever, so i searched it then I saw Brian Viglione and I was like WTFOHMAGAWD!!!!What a coinkidink

mostdangerouscupcake Says:

Mar 28, 2008 - I just shat myself.

NicoleAnachronism Says:

Mar 29, 2008 - oh, and he has an AMAZING voice, he should do a singing side project..

thinkplay Says:

Apr 3, 2008 - He does Nicole, he performs solo.

PinkOnBlack Says:

May 18, 2008 - Seriously, is there anything that could make Brian any hotter?

ricarleite Says:

Jun 22, 2008 - He forgot the lyrics?

ihateyouropinion Says:

Jul 12, 2008 - If I had never heard Jeff Mangum sing this, I would love this.. however, I can't help but compare... and Jeff just trumps Brian. However, I def think Brian should sing on more Dresden Dolls tracks... and not just background. But it is cool to see that the bands that I love are fans of other bands i love, too.

poopycool Says:

Jul 27, 2008 - jesse lacey does this so much better

Bitfromtheinside Says:

Aug 18, 2008 - Such a better cover then that Brand New cover.

hellofditties Says:

Aug 30, 2008 - This is a nice idea. But, it is my favourite song of all time, and I would have liked to see Amanda sing it. Maybe she could have done it justice?

CaffeinatedCassadie Says:

Sep 1, 2008 - I adore Brians singing voice. He needs to do it more often.

musicalpony Says:

Sep 12, 2008 - i do think that amandas voice is great but in the past when she did a cover of a neutral milk song it was really not that good, and i think that brian did a fairly good job with this

oursocalledfriend Says:

Oct 12, 2008 - I love the Dresden Dolls, but this fucking murdered possibly the greatest lyricism and live take of all time. If you are going to cover such a song, you need to either be really good, or make it yours, this was neither. It was a poor man's version of how Mangum performed it. At least when Palmer does two headed boy she brings something extra to the song, changes it a touch.Good on him for having good taste though.