Hadith: Women Deficient?

eziad85 Says:

Sep 28, 2008 - stop making an idiot of yourself and get an interpretation

ggyyvvxx Says:

Oct 6, 2008 - TAPS711You first quoted a hadiyth but the hadiyth are words of man not the Divine Words of Allah nor do tey have anything to do with Islaam. True Islaam eminates from Al Qur'aan and the verse that you quoted Qur'aan 4:34 that says "beat them" is a mistranslation, that is not the true context of that verse.

ggyyvvxx Says:

Oct 6, 2008 - You must not read the Qur'aan because the Qur'aan makes it very clear that men and women are SPIRITUAL EQUALS OF ONE ANOTHER, read:Qur'aan 3:195Also readQuraan 4:124 As for those who lead a righteous life, male or female, while believing, they enter Paradise, and never suffer the slightest harm. Quraan 16:97 Quraan 40:40

muslimah4lifenbeyond Says:

Oct 7, 2008 - spiritually equal. not equal in EVERYTHING, which totally makes sense. depending on each gender's way of handling things means that they both get different responsibilites & therefore different rights. {Quran 4:34, "...God has give one more (strength) than the other}

muslimah4lifenbeyond Says:

Oct 7, 2008 - TAPS711 wasnt lying abt that hadith; the 1 u quote is a different one & he quoted another one. BUT in context of the whole hadith, it actually shows the love prophet Muhammad (s) had 4 Ayesha (ra). reading the whole hadith, & better yet, listening 2 it makes the whole situation very clear.a quick explanation: prophet Muhammad (s) hit her b/c she thought that he could kinda cheat on her. & prophet Muhammad (s) said sumthing like, 'do u not trust me'...u will understand it better if u read it

seamr05 Says:

Oct 7, 2008 - Thank you for the information, sister;) But can you give me a concrete source of reference, where I can look it up? The first google seaches show islamofobic/hating articles.

coccinelsucrer Says:

Oct 9, 2008 - Well i've always been interested in how humans work and the differences between males and females and men's left hemisphere (which is all about rationality and logic and mathematics) is bigger than their right hemisphere ( the emotions and stuff like that) while the two hemispheres are EQUAL when it comes to females, so no it is not totally true when she says that emotional side works more than the rational side all the rest is about hormones

coccinelsucrer Says:

Oct 9, 2008 - But that does in no way mean that all the women should be judged the same, ONLY because they're women, you can't judge someone by his gender! So this does not justify the fact that mohammed called women DEFICIENT in intelligence simply because de word "deficient" itself is tactless and harsh and clearly inapropriate. Just because we're not like men doesn't mean we're deficient, that's insulting!

coccinelsucrer Says:

Oct 9, 2008 - XD WTH would aisha struck mohammed that's nonsense!! Mohammed went somewhere at night and he didn't notice that Aisha had been following him so when he noticed her presence he struck her, if you don't believe it look up the numbers.

seamr05 Says:

Oct 13, 2008 - I did look it up...and now I have a better understanding of what really went on. And I will find the hadith that said that aicha (r.a)struck our prophet, don't worry about it...

Pelsen85 Says:

Oct 19, 2008 - all hot guys reading this hit me up on MSN Messenger ID jane23belle. im bored xD N

PurgingFalsehood Says:

Oct 19, 2008 - Many many hadiths are forged.Quran is base of Islam; not Hadith books. Hadith books shud be taken just as history report. because when u take them as history reports , u will not make them as dogma. and when u will not make them dogma, u will not be compelled to believe even on many false reports of Hadiths books. and u will not be forced to belive on all over 5280 forged hadiths of Abu Hurayra whom Umar Khattab and Aisha R.A said a liar, stealer, theif and dishonest person who fabricate hadiths

PurgingFalsehood Says:

Oct 19, 2008 - At the time of the farewell Pilgrimage, Last sermon, Our Master Prophet Muhammed (S) Said:"I left for you what if you hold up to, you will never be misguided, the BOOK OF GOD."(Reference: Muslim 15/19, nu 1218; Ibn Majah 25/84, Abu dawud 11/56.) (Not 6 books written by Persian Mullas in which they have insulted many times Allah & prophet too)JUST BOOK OF GOD ---- JUST BOOK OF GOD ----- JUST BOOK OF GOD

PurgingFalsehood Says:

Oct 19, 2008 - Zayd Ibn Thabit (the Prophet's closest revelation writer) visited the Khalifa Mu'aawiya (more than 30 years after the Prophet's death), and told him a story about the Prophet. Mu'aawiya liked the story and ordered someone to write it down. But Zayd said, "The messenger of God ordered us never to write anything of his Hadith." (Reported by Ibn Hanbal)

PurgingFalsehood Says:

Oct 19, 2008 - (Quran verse 39:23) "God bestows from on high the best of all HADITH in the shape of a divine writ fully consistent within itself, repeating each statement [of the truth] in manifold forms....(O Prophet) These messages of God do We convey unto thee, setting forth the truth. In what other HADITH, if not in Gods messages, will they, then, believe? (Quran verse 45:6)

PurgingFalsehood Says:

Oct 19, 2008 - O my very dear beautiful & beloved but unwise fanatic speaker sister!!The hadiths that say that Woman is equal to black cat or dog (as is in false Bukhari) and the hadith that say that woman is defficient are forged reports and NEVER EVER SAID by our Master Last prophet Muhammad (S). Quran says, Birth of girl or son , both are blessings, Bible says birth of daughter is a LOSS

PurgingFalsehood Says:

Oct 22, 2008 - Truth about WomanWoman is more respectable than man, as woman gave birth to all prophets & Saints of Allah and woman is the FIRST the KINDEST teacher of Humanity. All human society is in debit of Woman; the most beautiful creation on planet. With out woman this world will be worse than a dry desert. Woman is mother under whom feet is Pradise, woman is sister who has the purest love for his brother, woman is wife with out which man is animal.(Pls note than I am a man)

onlyallah1 Says:

Nov 5, 2008 - AH SHUT UP woman are devil i know cuz i am a woman jk

yalittleboy Says:

Nov 14, 2008 - Most women are being respected In our islamic society than theirs, I'm saying that out of experience i've been living . I'm Egyptian and I live in the USA. I really do apriciate our muslim women, I apriciate my dad who tearted my mother respectfully, i respect our men in Egypt who love and care about their women.

yalittleboy Says:

Nov 14, 2008 - women here in the west are being used and abused so that they become wild and bite as a crazy dog. when we (muslim) men treat them kindly here in the west, thy think we are making use of the, because they have bad experiences from their own men. this women has a child or two by a man who left her alone with no help.

yalittleboy Says:

Nov 14, 2008 - women here in the states are being used for sex by men, being insulted and kicked and punshed in the face by their boy friends. women are being trated like a man, raised like a man, have to work to live. on the contrary, we treat our women like queens, and i'm talking about most of women not a strange case or cases or certain women.Finally I wanna say to Muslim women, LOOK UP YOU ARE PROUDLY MUSLIMAH, and we are muslim men apreciate you sisters.

uddathunni Says:

Nov 16, 2008 - muslima4lifenbeyond.. it was wrong on her part to suspect the love of prophet mohammed who had 11 wives, 23 slaves for sex and 101 servants for sex., and had raped some 1700 women in 22 years. He is a role model for present day muslims who are truing to emulate him. Alla hu Akbar. ,

muslimah4lifenbeyond Says:

Nov 16, 2008 - no it wasnt wrong on her part. anything that goes against ur way of precieving things, u simply deny it. even thought, Ayesha (ra) [being the youngest of the prophet's wives]herself stated that no man has more control over his sexual desires than Prophet Muhammad (s)! as 4 ur numbers of slaves, it is probably a correct figure, but u should realize that Allah has always allowed concubines since the time of Abraham (or mayb b4 that). & rapes? i dont believe he ever raped any1. ALLAHU AKBAR!

FictionsBlaster Says:

Nov 22, 2008 - If we read Sahih Muslim we find an authentic Hadith that Abu Hurayra was friend of Two jews converts Kaab Akhbar and wahab bin Munabba (in fact both were Munafiks), That Hadith tells us clearly that what ever these two Munafiks used to tell, Abu Hurayra was spreading them as Hadiths. I am not saying this, Sahih Muslim is saying this. So do not shout on me pls. All hadith that defame Woman & are fictions are from Abu Hurayra

PurgingFalsehood Says:

Nov 30, 2008 - Truth about WomanWoman is more respectable than man, as woman gave birth to all prophets & Saints of Allah and woman is the FIRST the KINDEST teacher of Humanity. All human society is in debit of Woman; the most beautiful creation on planet. With out woman this world will be worse than a dry desert. Woman is mother under whom feet is Pradise, woman is sister who has the purest love for his brother, woman is wife with out which man is animal.(Pls note that I am a man)