Prakash Karat on India US nuclear deal part2

utubecrazyharish Says:

Dec 17, 2007 - Im sure the deal will go thru...too much money at stake.....the left wd earn my respect if theystall it!

budnyr Says:

Apr 3, 2008 - he cries like a little baby, what kind of information is he giving? none really... just reiterating the stand the left parties have taken

WowieGuy Says:

Apr 21, 2008 - Communist TraitorCPI = Chinese Party of India

WowieGuy Says:

Apr 21, 2008 - Communist TraitorCPI = Chinese Party of India

ashrafmurga Says:

May 11, 2008 - He is one of the most stupid persons Indian politics has ever seen

vishalwall Says:

Jun 19, 2008 - kya bol ke gaya ye? ise achcha to koi gana suna deta..why cant a politician talk like a common man..ye sab padha likha banne ke chakkar main info kha jaate hain..

protikmaitra Says:

Jul 4, 2008 - Those who blindly support the deal are traitors. They are deliberately submitting India's sovereignty to the US. Some politicians will benefit, the country will suffer. Even with this deal, after 25 years, only 7% power will be generated from N-Plants. On the other hand, we tend to lose our independent foreign policy. Our petroleum security from Iran and Shakhalin will be jeopardised. Communists are not against the deal. Why is the PM silent on their concerns? N-Deal supporters are traitors.

protikmaitra Says:

Jul 4, 2008 - At least he is giving some facts. The N-Deal supporters are just saying, "It is good for India." Why is the PM silent on the concerns raised by the Left? Why is India included in the Hyde Act? Why is the 123 Agreement discriminatory? With the deal, even after 25 years, only 7% of our power will come from N-plants. What about the rest 93%? We need gas, and Iran pipeline is important. The US wants to attack Iran and is trying to change our foreign policy on Iran by Nuclear arm-twisting.

protikmaitra Says:

Jul 4, 2008 - Agar samajhme mahin ata, to chup chap baithe raho. Agar sare hinidustani Hyde Act, 123 Agreement aur NSG rules thik thak samajhte, to aaj yeh deal ka sawaal paida hi nahin hota. Congress ko bahut paisa milega US se, lekin desh ka kya hoga? Agar Left paisa leta, to Left bhi shayad chup rehta. Lekin Left paisa leta ki nahin, woh hi sochne ki baat hai. India-Today report: Left ke khilaf sabse kam corruption ka arop aya hai. Aur sabse zyada? Congress ke khilaf.

vishalwall Says:

Jul 4, 2008 - aap ko samjhta hai to samjhao na bhai..main to wahi bol raha hoon ki samjha nahin kya bol ke gaya.. waise jo bhasha bol rahe ho pade likhon ki to nahin lag rahi waise..

vishalwall Says:

Jul 4, 2008 - teenon samjhiye please ..hyde, 123, or nsg..

protikmaitra Says:

Jul 4, 2008 - Khud pade likhe hote to gana sunaneki baat nahin karte. Mera jawab kya apki tippani se kuchh alag hai?

protikmaitra Says:

Jul 4, 2008 - Main koi expert nahin hoon, lekin itna samjhta hoon ki current state mein yeh deal Hindustann ke liye achha nahin hai. Left deal ke khilaaf nahin hai; Left sirf 9 points of concern rakha hai, jiske upar Manmohan Singhji jawaab nahin de pa rahe hain. Hume nuclear power chahiye, leking uske saath apni swatantrata bhi banaye rakhne honge. Sirf, "Deal is good for us" bolne se kya hota hai?

vishalwall Says:

Jul 5, 2008 - koi baat nahin hai...

vishalwall Says:

Jul 6, 2008 - US wants to save India from economic recession post israel-iran war because of US FDI.. we all know that..we know the politics..tell us abut the deal..dont ask questions here..give answers..if you are not an expert then please stop behaving like one..

protikmaitra Says:

Jul 6, 2008 - Ok, assuming you are an expert. Tell me, 14 out of 22 Indian reactors will come under foreign (US) inspection, which is 64% of India's N-reactors. Will Indians be able to inspect 64% of all US reactors? Is the deal equal? Now you answer this question, Mr. Expert. I can throw many more questions at you, but you will not be able to answer. You wanted Karat to sing a song right? Why don't you just get off your computer and go watch MTV?

protikmaitra Says:

Jul 6, 2008 - I am not behaving like an expert. I am asking questions, just as a citizen. If I were an expert I would have been on Talk Shows. The point is simple, Dr. Singh, our PM, who masterminded liberalisation, which of course benefited India, thinks he can guarantee the economic growth with this deal. However, in a democracy, the PM is expected to earn the confidence of his parliament, allies and to some extent, opposition. Let him just answer the 9-points laid down by the left, that's all!

vishalwall Says:

Jul 6, 2008 - are protik dada.. you say dont wanna behave like an expert but you always do.. I asked karat to raher sg a song bcause wht he spoke about was completey incomrehensible to my layman's brains..if you are iven a platform to talk about somethig then what's the point in saying incomprehensible things..itna peonally nahin lene ka dada..he is a smart man I know and also a good man..i respet him for what he is doing but also I thik he should make his point clear using simple language..sorry..no offence.

protikmaitra Says:

Jul 7, 2008 - No offense to you either, Vishal babu; if you think I am behaving like an expert, so be it. Finally, we all have different perceptions of what is good for India.

Achumama Says:

Jul 13, 2008 - Anyway BJP and its allies, Left and many MPs from the SP are against this anti India nuclear deal which is being forced upon the country by the Congress led UPA. Only a blind idiot who doesn't have the intellectual capability to understand the deal in fine detail will call a person opposed to the deal anti India. The criminals in the media have tried to manipulate the facts to influence public opinion.

crusadeever Says:

Jul 17, 2008 - pakistani muslims proudly killed 10 million hindus sikhs in 1947

styleso Says:

Jul 18, 2008 - u r withdrawal is too late

styleso Says:

Jul 18, 2008 - manmoman singh has outsmarted u. jnu is inferior to lse

indiaknight Says:

Jul 21, 2008 - commies are enemies of india. karat and co suck chini dick. bjp and commie are a marriage made in hell. No difference between commies and fascists.

abujahl007 Says:

Oct 12, 2008 - This communist has no right to speak for 1 billion Indians!